October 2, 2018:

This is Where to Get the Best Pizza in Barrie

If you’re coming from Toronto and you miss that little pizzeria down the road whose pizza tasted like somebody’s mama made it with pure love, never fear…we’ve asked around and have compiled a list our of top six, fan favourite pizzerias in Barrie.

This is where to get the best pizza in Barrie:

Pizzeria Italia

Pizzeria Italia is the place to be if you’re craving an authentic-tasting, traditional Italian pizza grounded with an unbelievably delicious tomato sauce and full crust. Situated just steps to Heritage Park in Kempenfelt Bay, this ideally located pizzeria sets the stage for a fun night out with friends to eat in or takeout. It’s the kind of understated, casual place that clearly says: we’re going to impress you with our food, not with our fancy, oversized plates and expensive lighting.

Address: 18 Mulcaster Street, Barrie*Price: 18″ XL Pizza $16.29 + toppingsAtmosphere: Grandma’s dining room casualKnown for: Homemade sauce, and full crust baked to perfection

Cocelli Pizza

Calling all Barrie Pizza lovers…Cocelli (pronounced CO-CHELLI) does not only serve up tasty pizza, but they also serve up hot pizza deals! Boasting a party-sized pizza at the loveable price of $16.99, this Barrie gem is one to keep in mind for your upcoming family pizza night.

Address: 241 Essa Rd., Barrie*Price: Party-sized pizza $16.99Atmosphere: Looks like your average walk-in pizza shop. Tastes like nona made it.Known for: No-frills pizza at a price you will love (available at takeout or delivery)


Racking up the positive reviews from loyal customers, Paezano’s is known for creating the delectable homemade dough…it’s no wonder it’s one of the best pizzas in Barrie. Striving to exceed their mission statement through every customer’s bite, Paezano’s aims to provide Barrie with delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients at an affordable price. Your mama would not be disappointed with this choice!

Address: 420 Leacock Dr., Barrie*Price: XL Classic pizza $16.99 (add a second XL pizza for just $13.99)Atmosphere: A one-stop, take-out shopKnown for: High-quality ingredients, and an authentic, homemade dough

Nino’s Italian Restaurant

Known to the community for their unpretentious Italian atmosphere and for serving familiar fare like chicken parmigiana, gourmet pizza & delectable spaghetti sauce, Nino’s Italian Restaurant has been successfully serving exceptional cuisine since 1973. Said best by their loyal customers “If you haven’t eaten here, you have to go. You won’t regret it.”

Address: 298 Blake St., Barrie*Price: Large classic pizza $14.50 – Speciality pizza $27.00Atmosphere: Casual, understated place where the food is the star of the showKnown for: Unpretentious Italian atmosphere and for serving familiar fare

The Italian Eatery:

Experience a taste of Italy in the comfort of your own backyard. Situated in the convenient location of Park Place, The Italian Eatery is a popular spot to grab a pizza lunch with your co-workers, an authentic Italian dinner with the family, or even a drink to cap off the day. Dine here to taste delicious gourmet pizzas draped in fresh toppings such as fiori di latte cheese, prosciutto, hot soppressata, and more.

Address: 90 Park Pl Blvd., Barrie*Price:18″ XL Pizza $22.00 – $24.00Atmosphere: Casual lunch break retreatKnown for: Gourmet Italian favourites doused in an array of fresh toppings

Cicco’s Ristorante

Enter Cicco’s Ristorante (pronounced CHEEK-OHS)to find an atmosphere of warmth and surrounded by the aroma of authentic Italian food. Serving five unique, delicious homemade options for the foodie in you, or customize your own, this hidden gem offers something for the whole family. Just ask their loyal customers. This is a great spot to enjoy date night or a night out with family and friends.

Address: 170 Prince William Way, Barrie*Price: Gourmet pizza $13.00-$15.50, or build your own 16″ 11.95 + toppingsAtmosphere: An upscale night outKnown for: “Where food and hospitality become one”

Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint

Time to plan the next family night out? birthday party? department lunch? How will you ever find something that everyone will agree on? Pie Wood Fire Pizza Joint has you covered. Boasting numerous locations around Simcoe County, Pie is a simple to spot, must-visit shop boasting a wide variety of pizzas that everyone is sure to enjoy! Serving up authentic pies for the adventure of the family or “just cheese” pies of the simple man, Pie Wood Fire Pizza Joint is sure to impress.

Address: 11 Victoria St, Barrie*Price: All pies between $9.00-$19.00Atmosphere: A welcoming atmosphere the whole family, team, or department will enjoyKnown for: A multitude of thin-crust pizzas baked in a stone oven that will have you asking for 5 more minutes with the menu

*Check restaurant website for most up-to-date pricing

Thinking of a move to the 705?


to get access to ournew listing inventorythat isn’t even on Realtor.ca yet…you have to be a FarisVIP member.It’s free and there’s no obligation.

Call us today at 1.888.918.6570, send us an email or book an appointment.

There’s absolutely NO OBLIGATION. Consultations with our team of experts are FREE.

Related Posts

  • April 25, 2023:

    Investing in Rental Properties in Barrie, ON: Everything You Need to Know

  • April 29, 2022:

    Our Clients Are Clients For Life!

  • March 2, 2022:

    Why Exceptional Marketing Matters in The 2022 Real Estate Market

Stay Connected

Get the latest real estate news, exclusive listings, home evaluations, and promotions in your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to our Terms & Privacy Policy.
You can easily cancel at any time by selecting the unsubscribe option.